Notion AI vs Elephas: Which is Better for Independent Professionals?
Both tools promise to make knowledge work faster. But for independent consultants who handle confidential client data, there's a decisive difference: one sends everything to the cloud, the other never leaves your Mac.
Quick comparison at a glance
| Feature | Notion AI | Elephas ⭐ |
|---|---|---|
| Offline Mode | ❌ No | ✅ Full |
| Privacy | ❌ Cloud | ✅ Local |
| Cost/mo | $8–10 + Notion plan | $8–14 all-in |
| Mac Native | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| Knowledge Base | ⚠️ Notion only | ✅ Any files |
| System-wide AI | ❌ No | ✅ Cmd+E |
| NDA-safe | ❌ No | ✅ Yes |
| File Types | Notion pages | PDFs, docs, any |
Notion AI: Deep Dive
What it is: AI features built directly into the Notion workspace. Available as a paid add-on to any Notion plan.
- Seamless Notion integration — AI where your notes already live
- Q&A over Notion pages and databases
- Strong writing assistance (rewrite, summarise, expand)
- AI-powered database queries and views
- No separate app to learn — same interface
- Cloud-only — all data processed on Notion's servers
- Expensive: $8–10/mo add-on on top of Notion subscription
- No offline access
- Slow Q&A on large Notion databases
- Only works on Notion content — no external file ingestion
Elephas: Deep Dive
What it is: A Mac-native AI knowledge assistant and writing tool. Processes everything locally on your device — your documents never touch a server.
- Full offline processing — zero network dependency possible
- Local privacy — data never leaves your Mac
- Super Brain ingests any file type (PDFs, Word, web clips)
- System-wide Cmd+E shortcut — works in every Mac app
- 20+ local AI models (Llama, Qwen, DeepSeek)
- Separate Super Brain per client = clean context separation
- Mac-only — no Windows, Linux, or web version
- Apple Silicon recommended for best local model performance
- Not a note-taking app — pairs with your existing notes tool
Feature-by-feature comparison
When to choose Notion AI
- Already deeply invested in the Notion ecosystem
- Need AI for Notion database management and page editing
- Don’t handle confidential or NDA-bound client data
- Primarily work in a browser environment
When to choose Elephas ⭐
- Handle confidential client data (NDAs, HIPAA, legal privilege)
- Need offline access (travel, secure facilities, restricted networks)
- Work across multiple Mac apps beyond Notion
- Want better ROI for a solo or boutique practice
Can you use both Notion AI and Elephas?
Yes — and many consultants do. Notion for project management: task boards, client meeting notes, CRM-light, and project wikis. Elephas for knowledge and document AI: deep research over client documents, proposal drafting, and any work involving confidential or NDA-bound files. The tools are complementary rather than competing when used this way. You get Notion's organisational structure without Notion AI's privacy limitations on sensitive content.
Decision guide: which tool is right for you?
Frequently asked questions
Can Elephas query my Notion pages?
Not natively via a Notion integration, but you can export Notion pages as Markdown or PDF and import them into an Elephas Super Brain. For consultants who use Notion primarily for project management (rather than as a knowledge repository), this workflow is practical. You get the privacy and offline benefits of Elephas alongside your Notion setup.
Is Notion AI cheaper than Elephas?
No — when you account for total cost, Notion AI is more expensive for most solo practitioners. Notion AI is an $8–10/month add-on on top of a Notion subscription ($8–16/month for paid plans). Total: $16–26/month minimum. Elephas is $8–14/month all-in, with no underlying platform subscription required.
Does Elephas replace Notion?
No, and it's not designed to. Notion is a project management and note-taking workspace. Elephas is an AI knowledge assistant and writing tool. They serve different purposes and work well together: use Notion for task management, client communications, and project tracking; use Elephas for document research, confidential Q&A, and AI-assisted drafting.
Which is better for proposal writing?
Elephas, for most consultants. Its Super Brain lets you ground proposals in actual client discovery notes, past engagement documents, and your firm's own methodology documents. The Cmd+E shortcut means you can get AI help while writing in any app — including Notion itself. Notion AI is better for expanding Notion-native content blocks, but it can't query external files.
Can I use Elephas if I'm not on Mac?
Currently, Elephas is Mac-only and works best on Apple Silicon (M1 and later) for local AI model performance. If you're on Windows or Linux, Elephas is not currently an option. Alternatives for non-Mac users who need privacy-conscious document AI include Msty (Windows/Linux) or locally-hosted open-source tools like AnythingLLM. For Mac-based consultants, Elephas has no comparable competitor.
Related resources
Your client data deserves better than the cloud
Elephas gives you the knowledge management power of Notion AI — without sending your confidential documents to anyone's server. Built for independent professionals who take privacy seriously.
Start Your Free Elephas Trial